Shifting Borders and Changing Designations — “The Old Home Place”

“The Old Brown Place” — as some members of the family — remember where Jess and Millie were living at the time of Jess’s death (October 1957) is actually located in the southwest corner of Logan County, Arkansas.

I thought I would try to help my Cartwright cousins who never actually saw where Jess and Millie lived in the 1950s to bring this location in focus but using the Family Maps information. It has proven a bit trickier than I thought it would be. Here is why.

When family members have tried to explain where the home place is located, they typically refer to the big curve in the road on Hwy 23 about a mile east of the intersection of Hwy 71 and Hwy 23. Others locate it in relation to the old Boy Scout Camp near the little community of Tate, which is located a bit further east (also in Logan County).

While “The Old Brown Place” may be the way local folks referred to this property in the mid-20th century, that location appears to have been homesteaded by a man named Samuel Fellner in 1888. See maps below from pp. 282-283 of the Logan County Family Maps volume, Township 4, North Range 29, West (5th PM) in Section 3.

Hwy 23 (Fellner location) IMG_0028

Samuel Fellner Place (SW Logan County) IMG_0026

I have not taken the time to trace the connection to see if the Brown family who homesteaded property almost two decades later further east in Logan County could be the folks who later lived on the Fellner homestead, but given the geography there may be some connection. See page 299 of the Family Maps of Logan County, Arkansas, Township 4, North Range 26, West (5th PM) in Section 6. The Brothers Brown — George and Walter — bought the land along Jack Creek in 1906 (see Family Maps diagram below).

The Old Brown Place -- Familly Map (Logan County)

Presumably the house where Jess and Millie lived was built sometime in the early years of the 20th century, because it was described as fairly old at the time they lived there. There is no house on the Brown place today, and I don’t think there has been since the 1970s. So, the best we can do is to watch for the County Line marker on Hwy 23 and remember that the Old Brown Place was located just east of the Scott County/Logan County Line.

I found it interesting to discover that there is a broader sense in which this area of Arkansas has been contested in local memory. The first name of the county was “Sarber” — a man who was regarded by most Arkansans as a “carpetbagger” —  but as soon as the leaders of Arkansas were able to escape from the clutches of Reconstruction they chose to rename the area for James Logan, a leader that the people of Western Arkansas felt better about commemorating. The border lines of Scott County was changed in a couple of ways over the years in relation to the two counties to its North (Sebastian, where Mansfield is located) and Logan (where Booneville is located).

Whether Jess and Millie enjoyed any particular advantage from having lived just over the county line, I do not presume to know. Elsewhere in the state of Arkansas (Moiuntain View in Stone County for example), bootleggers were known to take advantage of the local option laws that made it legal to have beer in one county, but not in the next one. Although Jess is known to have supplemented his income at times (during the Depression) by making moonshine (or so he told my mother Mary Frances Cartwright Wilson in 1956-57), we do not have any knowledge of him having been in conflict with local law enforcement officials over the matter.

Because this area is fairly rural, it is hard to say that there is anything particularly distinctive about this border area. Even so it always has felt odd to me to drive along Hwy 71 and quickly enter and exit Logan County en route to Scott County from Fort Smith. In March 2001, when Carolyn Hanna responded to my brother Paul’s query about the location of one of our family’s addresses, she joked that “people who live around there have a Booneville address, and a Mansfield phone number!” She was speaking about “Cedar Creek,” but that is just down the road from the little communities of Ione, Abbott, Boothe, Lucas, etc.  I do not know when Jess and Millie first had access to telephone service, but I know that during the 1950s, their address was “Rt. 2, Booneville, Arkansas.”

So while the original “home place” for the Cartwright clan was in Scott County, the places that my father Billy Cartwright and his siblings associated with “home” were in that area where the three counties came together. Less than seven miles separates the historical communities of Tate, Bloodsworth, Ione, Boothe, Abbott, Square Rock, Lucas, Elm Park, Freedom, and Packsaddle, but you have to really do some map manipulation to get them all in focus at the same time because of the way they are mapped in time and space.

The one thing that seems constant in the midst of the changing names of the communities in this area of Scott County and Logan County is the Petit Jean River, which snakes around in various ways throughout this open country before emptying into the Arkansas River. Most people do not refer to this western area as the Petit Jean River Valley, I think, because of the mountainous terrain (Poteau, Tate, etc.).  And when I think back to the stories my father Billy Cartwright would tell about this area, he always talked about things like fishing and hunting near “the old home place near Petit Jean River.”

If you would like to receive these posts by email, you can follow in the right sidebar.

About mcartwright1957

I am a member of the senior administrative team at the University of Indianapolis where I have served since 1996. I am married to Mary Wilder Cartwright. We are the parents of four children: Hannah, Erin, James, and Bethany. I currently live in Nashville, IN.
This entry was posted in from East to West, Questions of the Week and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Shifting Borders and Changing Designations — “The Old Home Place”

  1. Betty C. Scheffer-Halford says:

    Foster and I toured the area where we lived on Hwy 23 (the old Brown place) a few years ago. Betty

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s